From $2 jars of Skippy to $25 artisanal jars filled with sprouted seeds, there’s definitely no shortage of nut butters in the supermarket. But with such a variety of products on the shelf, it can be hard to know which jars are worth your cash. Is almond butter healthier than cashew butter? Can a $3 jar of “natural” peanut butter actually be healthy? If we’re being honest, no one has time to ask Siri all of these questions while staring at the display in the store—which is the very reason why we scoured the web for the best nut butter options online. This way, you can simply click, buy, and get your spoons ready.

Whether your grocery story lacks unique flavor varieties or you simply have no idea which jars are the healthiest picks, we’ve got you covered. Read on to discover the very best spreads you can nab at the click of a button. And if you wind up with some creamy leftovers, polish off your jars with the help of these 20 Delicious Nut Butter Recipes.

Classic jars of Jif and Skippy are highly processed and loaded with sugars and trans-fatty oils. But Crazy Richard isn’t about that life. All you’ll find in his jar of creamy goodness are peanuts, a legume that’s packed with heart-healthy monounsaturated fats that aid weight loss. You’d be hard-pressed to find a more wholesome spread for just $3, so be sure to snag a jar—stat!

Buy a jar online here, $3.19